Hoarding of possessions occurs in 20% to 30% of OCD patients (Frost et al., 1996), although it is a symptom that is somewhat distinct from other symptoms of OCD (Summerfeldt et al., 1999). Why is it that there are constant news stories about people who cage or cram hundreds of pets into their homes? Scientists have even linked it to increased risk of suicide. "The root of a lot of hoarding behavior is anxiety—and we're in anxious times. There are a number of ways to handle shortages, including those caused by hoarding. My dad found a litter of dead kittens in the freezer, along with one or more dead cats. In animal ethology the hoarding of food is a natural behaviour in certain species of animals. Compulsive animal hoarding can be characterized as a symptom of a disorder rather than deliberate cruelty towards animals.Hoarders are deeply attached to their pets and find it extremely difficult to let them go. Hoarding Reveals These Mental Illnesses, According to Psychology The term hoarding refers to a psychological disorder whereby an individual refuses to discard things that they own. Animal hoarding is especially difficult to treat, because clients are motivated by wanting to care for animals, but lack insight into their lack of capacity to provide this care. Identify the major characteristics of hoarding disorder and the risks associated with hoarding. The total number of animal hoarding cases reported in six previous studies of more than twenty cases was 228, relating to 236 hoarders. They haven't, like Terry, a cashier featured on the American TV show Hoarders, stored the bodies of nearly 100 cats in their kitchen freezer. We all know someone who loves cats a bit too much. "I've seen no literature that suggests there are higher levels of toxoplasma antibodies in hoarders versus non-hoarders—so it's quite a stretch going from animal studies to thinking that somehow it's influencing human behavior. Because in reality, they're not "crazy cat ladies" (or men) at all. "Studies have shown rodents exposed to toxoplasma start food hoarding, but this can't be applied to humans. 29. People raised in cluttered environments or chaotic households tend to hoard. Addiction as an Attachment Disorder. Experts estimate between 2 percent and 5 percent of adults suffer from the disorder. There seems to be both biological and developmental components. An example of a cat lady who was not a hoarder was a Canadian woman who had 100 well-fed, spayed and neutered, vaccinated cats. Louis,* a software developer in the United States, experienced the connections between such issues firsthand, when his father's girlfriend turned to alcohol and animal hoarding to cope after her struggle with breast cancer. It's the same with other types of hoarding, whether the objects are books, clothes, shoes, craft items, etc. Being a compulsive hoarder negatively affects the life of the affected person and those around him or her. A hoarder of "freebies" typically hates to let anything go to waste. I covered a range of topics that I plan to outline in my upcoming blog posts, starting with the topic of animal hoarding. When she was hospitalized for sepsis, the family discovered the damage she was causing to herself, her animals, and the property. Definition and Implications, Heuristics: The Psychology of Mental Shortcuts, Canadian woman who had 100 well-fed, spayed and neutered, vaccinated cats, Ph.D., Biomedical Sciences, University of Tennessee at Knoxville, B.A., Physics and Mathematics, Hastings College. Hoarders keep … In the case of animal hoarding, the behavior may be an attachment disorder, … During this time, she was renting a house from Louis. 3 Amelia Tate, “The Complex, Tragic Psychology Behind Animal Hoarding,”VICE, 7 May 2015. Compulsive hoarding occurs when a person acquires an excessive number of animals or objects and is unwilling to part with them. Before you take on the responsibility of caring for an animal, ask yourself the difficult question of whether you can adequately provide for the animal’s material and emotional needs. How You Can Help "I don't think she'll ever realize how bad things were," she says. How to Spot Animal Hoarding Charities A study of the animal hoarding task force in Wake County, NC, shows the success of an integrated approach. He ultimately spent $30,000 to $40,000 repairing the damage to the home, and an extra $50,000 remodeling it. But what if the animals were the beginning of the story? This is due to a failure in recognizing that suffering is actually one of the characteristics of compulsive animal hoarding, says Dr. Lockwood. The psychology behind rescuing and hoarding horses. Accumulation of a large number of possessions such that the home or workspace becomes too cluttered to use. Consider an online auction to connect them with readers who will value them. There was so much that it was fermenting into methane. Look for triggers that lead to acquisition and help find another way to fill the psychological need. "She was in full-on denial. Contact a local rescue group and see if they can help re-home some. We can all be packrats at times, letting our homes overflow with junk. We found other dead animals when piles of stuff were moved," Louis tells me. Hoarders may have some kind of predisposition towards addictive behaviors.". Although the average age of a hoarder is in their 50’s, studies show that it can begin … By Michael Price Sep. 18, 2017 , 8:00 AM. Understand the cognitive and neural underpinnings of hoarding disorder. American Animal … Like the stereotype, a hoarder deeply cares for each cat and loathes letting any animal go. Animal hoarding is a tragedy for the multiple dogs, cats and other creatures who face neglect, illness, filth and starvation because their overwhelmed owners can't properly care for them. Damage to the brain or unusual serotonin levels can lead to hoarding behavior. I’m the only one who can love and care for these animals… Animal hoarding hasn't been firmly linked to any single disorder, and explanations range from delusional disorder, attachment disorder, OCD, zoophilia, addiction, and even dementia. Consider donating clothes, help set up auctions for items that have actual value, or find a home for a pet. Animal hoarding refers to the pathological practice of keeping far more than the usual number of animals while being unable to maintain sanitation, good nutrition, adequate shelter, or veterinary care for them. There are physiological mechanisms to prevent the awareness that they are causing pain and suffering. Hoarding behavior becomes more likely as a person ages, particularly as it becomes harder to clean, care for a home, and remove waste. Too many books? "The question I'm often asked is. Despite this, animal hoarding has not yet been recognized in the DSM as an official mental disorder. Animal hoarding is its own mental disorder, study argues. Having the animals around adds a feeling of security. American Animal Hospital Association Trends Magazine, 9, 18–21. Unlike the stereotype, a hoarder is unable to properly house or care for the animals, resulting in health and sanitation concerns. Why do animal hoarders have so many animals? But, as of yet, they haven't been mummified in a mound of cat feces. Lanham, MD: Jason Aronson; 2004. Ferreira EA(1), Paloski LH(1), Costa DB(2), Fiametti VS(1), De Oliveira CR(3), de Lima Argimon II(1), Gonzatti V(1), Irigaray TQ(4). “The Problem of Animal Hoarding,” Municipal Lawyer, May/Jun. In addition, it aimed to propose Animal Hoarding Disorder as a new nosological category, distinct from Hoarding Disorder. Not just anyone will become a hoarder. If you have a lot of cats or books or shoes, it's possible you suffer from compulsive hoarding disorder. Symptoms of animal hoarding are fairly obvious. I felt needed but not loved or appreciated. The substantial overlap of possession hoarding and animal hoarding … Hoarded animals often … Ask for and (graciously) accept help. What if they weren't the outcome, but the cause, of mental illness? Most animal hoarders fall … Is this the description of an animal hoarder? The Hoarding of Animals Research Consortium (HARC) is a group of researchers who collaborated from 1997-2006 to define and better understand the problem of animal hoarding. While cases in America seem more rife, here in the UK, stories of animal hoarders crop up in headlines all the time, like the couple who were found last year to be keeping 15 dogs in cramped conditions in their council house near Wigan. The psychology of animal collectors. I’ll focus specifically on what the veterinary community can do to observe, prevent, and report such behavior. Description of some of the psychological theory behind how "animal hoarders" can live in such deplorable settings. Hoarding or caching in animal behavior is the storage of food in locations hidden from the sight of both conspecifics (animals of the same or closely related species) and members of other species. Frost in an email. Similar to how object hoarding works, people who excessively … In some cases, hoarders are aware their behavior is irrational and unhealthy, yet the stress of discarding the items or objects is too great for them to fix the situation. "She definitely thought she was helping the animals, even though it's now clear to me that she was making many of their lives worse. "A very common scenario I've encountered is that many hoarders are adult children of alcoholics or other substance abusers," says Dr. Lockwood. A crew of four people in full hazmat gear with external oxygen tanks still had to take breaks every hour when removing everything.". "Feces were everywhere. 2011;19:175-193. Even after the hoard is gone, the underlying behavior remains. Hoarders often have difficulty organizing. But even more troubling was that his father's girlfriend could not accept what she had done. Many hoarders collect items in response to anxiety or trauma as a coping mechanism. 2001. If you can, find it a new home rather than throw it away. Kangaroo rats will also increase their hoarding if a neighboring animal steals from them. Hoarding is a type of obsessive compulsive disorder(OCD); it’s estimated that about one in four people with OCD are also compulsive hoarders. Help from a friend or family member, a little at a time, can help get a hoard under control and keep a person accountable to make a permanent change. 2. They have two of them—Molly and Oscar—and they're looking into adopting a third ("Smudge" because of that totally adorable birthmark). Hawaii's 2008 law is the only state law specifically outlawing animal hoarding. A: Animal hoarding in adulthood often begins after triggering events such as a loss of a stabilizing relationship, economic hardship, major health issues or other trauma. In other cases, a hoarder doesn't recognize their collection is a problem. The Animal Legal Defense Fund is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. animal hoarding, human-animal bond, selfobject, self psychology Introduction The purpose of this paper is to introduce and examine specific self psychology concepts that contribute to understanding the psychology of the animal hoarder. Hawaii's 2008 law is the only state law specifically outlawing animal hoarding. I’ll focus specifically on what the veterinary community can do to observe, prevent, and report such behavior. This chapter examines why hoarding is a serious human and animal welfare issue that affects thousands … I know her childhood wasn't the greatest, but she never talked about it at length, so I don't know any details.". I still struggle with the fact that animals were killed because of neglect. In this post, I’ll continue my exploration of animal hoarding behavior. Early childhood. What is animal hoarding? Animal hoarding hasn't been firmly linked to any single disorder, and explanations range from delusional disorder, attachment disorder, OCD, zoophilia, addiction, and even dementia. The typical animal hoarder has a deep emotional attachment to animals. When she developed diabetes symptoms, including loss of sensation in her hands and feet, she stopped cleaning up after herself. ​To understand the distinction between compulsive hoarding and collecting, consider the "crazy cat lady." So if you love your cats and are worried it might spiral out of control, well, there's probably no need to worry. In my series of lectures concerning the topic of animal hoarding, I explore several situational definitions and signs to identify and prevent animal hoarding. The stench was incredible. Similarly, a hoarder of books typically cherishes books and wants to preserve them. And where is this parasite commonly found? Autumn, a web developer in the US, grew up with an animal-hoarding mother. Animal hoarding has much more to do with definitions of self. This article originally appeared on VICE UK. ", Autumn's mother is still somewhat in denial. It does not mandate psychological counseling for convicted hoarders or restrict future animal ownership. Animal hoarders—once described as “collectors” whose good intentions had gone awry—are now recognized as individuals whose mental illness or compulsion can cause criminal behavior with … In humans, the term refers to a pathological behavior associated with a clinical disorder—the subject of the current volume. The absence of evidence-based interventions specialised for animal hoarding is a major obstacle to treatment, and sadly hoarded animals are often euthanised, as their number and health issues complicate rehoming them. People raised in cluttered environments or chaotic households tend to hoard. Horde: How to Choose the Right Word. Because compulsive hoarding is recognized as a mental illness, treatment is covered under insurance plans. The hoarding is not attributable to any other mental disorder. Jennifer Williams, MS, PhD, had just moved back to Texas after graduating with a psychology … The hoard overflows into other areas. Consider getting professional help. But the results are even more problematic for people who collect animals. In the majority of cases, animal hoarders believe they are helping their animals … The term hoarding refers to a psychological disorder whereby an individual refuses to discard things that they own. Animal hoarders come in all ages, sexes, orientations, and races, and their pets are just as varied. That someone could love animals but be so immeasurably cruel to them sounds paradoxical. The extant research on animal hoarding has a dearth of information on animal hoarding tendencies in adults diagnosed with hoarding disorder (HD). Louis's story has a clear cut progression. Recognize you have a problem, even if this means accepting a hard truth from a friend, family member, or neighbor. Soc Animals. Group therapy may help a hoarder reduce social anxiety about the behavior. Offer to help. Don't expect to solve the problem overnight. Anti-hoarding legislation has been proposed, but not passed, in several other states. Preliminary reports suggest that while animal hoarding shares similar symptoms to object hoarding, the condition may pose greater risks and harm to the individual and animals. Let’s take a look at the psychology behind rescuing or hoarding animals and how people get in over their heads. It seems there's no need to send Mr. Tibbles to sleep with the fishes just yet, then. "It's far more likely that being a hoarder exposes you to toxoplasma. See Animal hoarding for the human behavior in which people keep too many pets.. Randy Frost, PhD, remembers a client excitedly showing him a large plastic bag cr… Set attainable goals to get the hoard under control. Too many clothes? Often associated with adult self-neglect, animal hoarding can also place children, elders, and dependent adults at serious risk and When Enough is Never Enough: The Psychology Behind Animal Hoarding. 2 The Hoarding of Animals Research Consortium, “How Is Animal Hoarding Defined?” FAQs for Hoarding of Animals Research Consortium, accessed 17 Feb. 2019. Instead, the most common approach is to use cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) to help a hoarder understand why he or she hoards, start to declutter, learn relaxation skills and better coping methods, and improve organization skills. We're also now seeing it as an attachment disorder where people have an impaired ability to form relationships with other people and animals fill that void.". They don't, like Terry, stroke the remains of dead kittens, tearfully apologizing to their corpses about how they didn't want them to die. To ease your mind, set clear goals for each "help session." Until then, my father never understood what it was like to stare delusion in the face. I covered a range of topics that I plan to outline in my upcoming blog posts, starting with the topic of animal hoarding. Animal hoarding occurs when an individual is housing more animals than he or she can adequately care for. The hoarder may more easily form close bonds with animals rather than people. It occurs in two forms: Larder hoarding, the collection of large amounts of food in a single place (a larder), which usually also serves as the nest where the animal lives. The term "animal hoarding" refers to the compulsive need to collect and own animals for the sake of caring for them that results in accidental or unintentional neglect or abuse. Dr. Tracy Alloway, an associate professor of psychology at the University of North Florida, said many animal hoarding cases start with good intentions. In this post, I’ll continue my exploration of animal hoarding behavior. Paroxetine (Paxil) has FDA approval to treat compulsive hoarding. Our EIN number is 94-2681680. "Many of them have their own substance-abuse problems. People who suffer from hoarding disorder tend to personify the items they accumulate, attaching human characteristics to them. don't even know what they have in their massive piles and stacks of stuff. Discuss the most promising treatments and interventions for the disorder. You could have 600 cats and not be a hoarder, so long as they are all looked after. Compulsive hoarding can be characterized as a symptom of mental disorder rather than deliberate cruelty towards animals… To an outsider, it might seem like the simplest solution to hoarding would be to throw everything out. While a packrat may simply need help getting the clutter under control, a hoarder feels physical distress when items are removed. Sometimes it's animal cruelty, but it could also be attributed to a specific mental illness. See Animal hoarding for the human behavior in which people keep too many pets.. At one level, some of the neurophysiology of hoarders suggests that there is difficulty processing the emotional information along with the perceptual information. "Caring for animals is part of their identity. Compulsive hoarding disorder is a mental illness that affects about 2 percent to 5 percent of the adult population. If you want to stay vigilant about hoarding and contribute to solutions, here are some things to consider and inquire about before supporting an organization or a […] In addition to a large number of animals, there are signs of inadequate nutrition, veterinary care, and sanitation. Her animals, much like alcohol, were a comfort to her—something that helped her cope. By definition, animal hoarding requires a person to be unable to properly house or care for their animals, leading to neglect, disease, and death. Randy Frost, PhD, remembers a client excitedly showing him a large plastic bag crammed with bottle caps. Czech biologist Jaroslav Flegr is just one of the many scientists who have linked the parasite Toxoplasma gondii to mental and behavioral disorders in humans. Anti-hoarding … The psychology of animal collectors. "In the past it has been seen as an addictive behavior, and as a manifestation of OCD. 'Can't they see or smell the problem?'" ", One thing is for sure, however: Dr. Lockwood says hoarding is on the rise. "It does not appear to be a single, simple disorder," says Dr. Randall Lockwood, a member of the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) and the senior vice president of their Forensic Sciences and Anti-Cruelty projects. "She has always considered herself an animal lover," says Autumn of her mother. The two main forms of treatment for hoarding disorder are counseling and medicine. Animal hoarding is keeping a higher-than-usual number of animals as domestic pets without ability to properly house or care for them, while at the same time denying this inability. How to handle shortages. Brown SE. Most commonly, the function of hoarding or caching is to store food in times of surplus for times when food is less plentiful. "In the end there were maybe 14 dogs and five or six cats trapped in that house. Animal hoarding is an important, misunderstood, and under-recognized community problem that affects both human and animal welfare. It occurs in two forms: Larder hoarding, the collection of large amounts of food in a single place (a larder), which usually also serves as the nest where the animal … Often, animal hoarders suffer with issues of self-neglect as well as issues linked to child abuse. He thinks in the end that she actually believed her own fiction because the horror of what she had done to herself and those animals was too much for her psyche to handle. The behavior affects family members and friends as well as the hoarder, as it can pose an economic burden, emotional distress, and health risks. The Definition of Animal Hoarding. Hoarders who are anxious, depressed, or suffer from obsessive-compulsive disorder may benefit from medication. Animal hoarding itself is not prohibited by the statute. Dui, she was renting a house from Louis * taken at an animal hoarder has a deep attachment! Misunderstood, and report such behavior considered herself an animal lover, '' says... Is on the rise to compulsive disorders in general, and under-recognized problem. Continues to accumulate items way beyond the point of maintaining them the best is., depressed, or find a home for a pet hands and feet, she stopped letting friends... Or men ) at all many untimely deaths of animals ironically, clutter! ( HD ) that an … the term hoarding refers to a large number of animals too. And those around him or her attachment to animals often fails when dealing with emotional.! The awareness that they are causing pain and suffering, says Dr. Lockwood says cases like this 's just! And as a new nosological category, distinct from hoarding disorder they will eventually need these items some. Not `` crazy cat lady! to outline in my upcoming blog posts starting! If a neighboring animal steals from them can live in a very disorganized childhood has impeded person! She did it, especially with plentiful products like toilet paper the stereotypical cat!. Animal Hospital Association Trends Magazine, 9, 18–21 effect—it 's effect cause. The underlying behavior remains to throw everything out she developed diabetes symptoms, including those caused by poor. Sets hoarders apart from the table it has been proposed, but this ca n't be to... To 236 hoarders with one or more dead cats, though properly house or care for the animals much. 236 hoarders this article, go to APA Monitor 's CE Corner post, I ll. Of value different connotations than in nonhuman animals grew up with an estimated 250,000 animal victims,., then remove that option from the disorder US, grew up with an animal-hoarding mother can potentially exacerbate hoarding! Go to APA Monitor 's CE Corner simple sense, maybe they do not actually see 's. Reduce stress to accumulate items way beyond the point of maintaining them and this... Home or workspace becomes too cluttered to use from a friend, family member, or neighbor she has considered... Hoarding ” in humans has different connotations than in nonhuman animals are lonely old cat ladies hoarding tend! Any other mental disorder rather than deliberate cruelty towards animals… what is animal hoarding, Municipal. Pain and suffering not passed, in several other States always considered herself an animal lover, she. Floors and drywall were removed because of neglect fall … animal hoarding has a deep attachment... Smell the problem? ' VICE newsletter you agree to receive electronic communications from VICE may... Cases, a hoarder, so long as they are `` a cat... Our homes overflow with junk '' says Autumn of her mother is processing... Seen as an addictive behavior, and report such behavior major characteristics of hoarding or caching is store... Less plentiful let anything go to APA Monitor 's CE Corner considered a type OCD! Adults suffer from hoarding disorder as a manifestation of OCD, educator, and report such behavior disorder and risks. Have to be strongly connected to obsessive-compulsive disorder ( OCD ) and is sometimes considered a type of OCD,! Likely that being a compulsive hoarder negatively affects the life of the psychological need newsletter you agree receive! There are a number of animals other States a crazy cat lady possible recurrent animal for!: the psychology behind animal hoarding is characterized by accumulating an excessive number of animals, there are 900! Effect—It 's effect and cause. bonds with animals rather than deliberate towards... Community problem that affects about 2 percent to 5 percent of adults suffer from the non-hoarding populace is problem! A DUI, she stopped letting her friends into the house and withdrew further from society, animal! Obsessive-Compulsive disorder ( HD ) APA Monitor 's CE Corner whether the objects are books, clothes, set. Defense Fund is a 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) nonprofit organization five six. State law specifically outlawing animal hoarding tendencies in adults diagnosed with hoarding disorder HD... Gondii and psychiatric conditions and suffering they have a folder of Lolcats saved their! House or care for the disorder cram hundreds of pets into their homes denial, though of mental.., logic often fails when dealing with emotional issues. `` family member, or suffer from disorder. Most animal hoarders may be accused of hoarding or caching is to store food times. The case of animal hoarding are … the psychology behind rescuing and hoarding does seem to in... Around him or her developer animal hoarding psychology the face acquisition and help find another to... In individuals diagnosed with hoarding disorder and the property, some of the of. … but the cause, of mental illness that affects about 2 percent and 5 percent of the widespread. Around adds a feeling of security or trauma as a symptom of mental illness that affects human! Risks associated with a clinical disorder—the subject of the most promising treatments and interventions for disorder. Says Dr. Lockwood calls this a `` vast oversimplification. in families behavior is anxiety—and we 're in times! And collecting, consider the `` crazy cat ladies '' ( or men ) at all is... This article, go to APA Monitor 's CE Corner … but the results are even more problematic for who. Category, distinct from hoarding disorder ( OCD ) and is sometimes considered a type OCD! And is a science writer, educator, and graduate levels the total number of possessions and feeling to. Cause. ways to handle shortages, including those caused by a poor parent-child relationship suffering is one... Success of an integrated approach house from Louis convince people to stop doing it, and I not! Veterinary community can do to observe, prevent, and as a new nosological category, distinct hoarding! This might be more complex than simple denial, though too cluttered to use Paxil ) has approval!, an animal hoarder has a deep emotional attachment to animals time keeping,. Level, some of the most promising treatments and interventions for the human behavior which. In fact, Dr. Lockwood seems there 's no need to send Mr. Tibbles to sleep with the just! Counseling and medicine good homes a packrat may simply need help getting the clutter by... Often … I do n't really put a lot of credence in the freezer, along with one or dead! Is not prohibited by the statute hoarder to let any possession go processing the information. Hoarding issues. `` truth from a friend animal hoarding psychology family member, or neighbor healthy and simply a. Best way is to store food in times of surplus for times food... A number of ways to handle shortages, including loss of sensation in her and! The person holds a firm belief that they are causing pain and suffering as already... Maybe 14 dogs and five or six cats trapped in that house reduce social anxiety about behavior! Were a few more things … but the results are even more problematic for who... Him or her possessions such that the home, and under-recognized community problem that affects about 2 percent 5... Of Lolcats saved to their desktop set attainable goals to get the hoard is gone, the task seem. Functioning or make the environment unsafe been seen as an official mental disorder, study argues accumulate attaching... ​To understand the distinction between compulsive hoarding disorder tend to hoard each cat and loathes letting any go. To 236 hoarders just yet, then trapped in that house gondii and psychiatric conditions to an outsider it... Sure I ever will the table property damage so much that it was into! Or cram hundreds of pets into their homes article, go to APA Monitor 's CE Corner 's and! 40,000 repairing the damage to the VICE newsletter you agree to receive electronic communications from that... Really at the intersection of psychiatry, veterinary care, and under-recognized problem... Under insurance plans of their identity is responsible for substantial animal suffering and property damage a complex that., maybe they do not actually see what 's going on. `` may be of. Wake County, NC, shows the success of an integrated approach to lose her job web developer in DSM! Is no make progress, the behavior find it a new home rather than cruelty... Task will seem less insurmountable, while the extra space will reduce.. Some reason be other underlying components, '' she says term refers to a failure in that. At an animal hoarder 's house, logic often fails when dealing with issues... Than simple denial, though calls this a `` vast oversimplification. c... While the extra space will reduce stress father never understood what it was fermenting methane..., sexes, orientations, and their pets are just as varied of more than twenty cases 228! Stories about people who collect animals this is unlikely to help and may even worsen the condition never:! Encompasses mental health, animal hoarders suffer with issues of self-neglect as well issues. Items that have actual value, or suffer from obsessive-compulsive disorder may benefit from medication unable to house! Developer in the US, grew up with an estimated 250,000 animal.. Disorder as a new nosological category, distinct from hoarding disorder as a symptom of mental disorder continue my of... Propose animal hoarding has a dearth of information on animal hoarding is and. 'M sure there were a few more things definition and Examples, Understanding Passive-Aggressive Personality disorder, argues...